It has been known for some time that the IMF considers Greek debt unsustainable and that any credible programme requires writing off a substantial proportion. But it is only on the eve of the Greek parliament voting on a brutally severe package of measures that it has said so openly and formally. Now, the creditors must be ready if the Greeks are to be expected to adopt measures which pile more pain on its already strained social fabric, to do what they are telling the Greeks to do: to face up to reality and admit that they have also made huge mistakes in the handling of Greek membership of the euro rate back to its flawed admission in 2002 and that by lending to Greece irresponsibly they did far more harm than good to the Greek people, acting little better than a backstreet loan shark.
It is pointed out that Greece’s votes for the Syriza government in January and in the July 5th referendum have to be balanced against the democratic wishes of the other 18 euro zone member states. But it should also be pointed out that whereas every Greek man, woman and child (except for a tiny minority with wealth held abroad) has had their lives drastically altered for the worse over the last six years, the impact on the lives of German or Dutch workers of writing off half of Greece’s debt would hardly be noticeable. Indeed actually it would just amount to acknowledging the reality that the money was lost when it was recklessly lent in the 2000s. Politicians in such countries would suffer scorn by the popular press but if the issue was tackled there would then be a reasonable possibility that Greece could recover and so no longer dominate the politics and newspaper headlines of the euro zone.